How to Increase the Average Order Value of an Online Store?

Picture of Blai Torras

Blai Torras

Marketing Manager

Summarise this article using AI:

TL;DR
Increasing average order value requires reviewing the profitability of each order, not just encouraging customers to buy more. Pricing, profit margins and logistics can all affect an ecommerce business’s bottom line. That is why it is essential to analyse the business structure before implementing sales strategies. It is also important to ensure that each strategy increases order value without reducing profit margins.

Increasing average order value is one of the most efficient ways to improve ecommerce profitability. It does not require more traffic, more advertising investment or acquiring new customers. It simply requires each customer who has already decided to buy to spend a little more.

The key strategies to achieve this are:

  1. Clearly communicating how to qualify for free shipping
  2. Upselling on product pages
  3. Product bundles
  4. Cross-selling with complementary products
  5. AI-powered “Frequently Bought Together” recommendations
  6. Volume discounts
  7. Samples or low-cost products added to orders
  8. Additional product-related services

But before implementing any of these strategies, there are two operational factors that determine whether they will be profitable.

What Needs to Be Sorted Out Before You Start

Optimised Shipping Costs

Increasing average order value by adding items to the cart is only profitable if shipping costs do not rise at the same time. For heavy, bulky products or international deliveries, adding a second item may mean needing a larger box, moving into a higher weight bracket or even arranging two separate shipments. In that case, the additional margin generated by the second item is absorbed by logistics costs.

Before implementing strategies to increase average order value, you need to understand the actual shipping cost for each product combination. Without this information, some seemingly profitable actions may actually be generating losses on each order.

Shipping Optimised for Product Combinations

Not all products work well together from a logistics perspective. A bundle that looks attractive on paper may create packaging, weight or handling issues that increase operating costs. Optimising shipping for different product combinations is a preliminary step that many ecommerce businesses overlook, which then directly affects the actual profit margin on each order.

The 8 Strategies to Increase Average Order Value

1. Clearly Communicating How to Qualify for Free Shipping

This is the most underrated strategy and one of the most effective. A clear message such as “You’re just €8 away from free shipping” on the product page or in the cart gives customers a very specific motivation: adding more to their order to avoid paying for delivery.

The behaviour is predictable: customers actively look for something to add to reach the threshold. If the products suggested at that moment are relevant, the conversion rate is very high.

To implement it effectively:

The free shipping threshold needs to be visible from the start — in the website header, on the product page and in the cart. Not as small print, but as an active element that updates based on the contents of the cart.

The amount remaining to reach the threshold should be communicated dynamically. “You’re X€ away from free shipping” is much more effective than “Free shipping on orders over €40” because it personalises the message based on the customer’s current order.

The threshold must be calculated with profit margins in mind. If offering free shipping on orders over €30 eliminates the profit margin on orders between €30 and €35, the threshold has been calculated incorrectly. The free shipping threshold must be profitable — or at least break even — for the ecommerce business.

2. Upselling on Product Pages

Upselling involves offering an upgraded version of the same product — a larger quantity, a better format or a premium edition — at the moment customers are considering a purchase. It is not a different product, but the same product with greater value.

It works well when the price difference between the basic and upgraded versions is small compared to the additional benefit. “For just €5 more, get the 250ml size instead of the 150ml version” is an easy decision for customers who have already decided to buy.

Upselling should be presented as a benefit to the customer, not as an attempt to sell them more. The comparison between versions needs to be clear, visual and easy to understand. If customers have to do calculations to work out which option suits them best, friction increases and the likelihood of an upsell decreases.

The most important distinction: upselling works before the cart, on the product page. Once customers reach the cart, it is already too late — they have made their decision, and interrupting it leads to abandonment rather than conversion.

3. Product Bundles

Grouping several products into a bundle at a combined price slightly lower than the sum of their individual prices is an effective strategy for increasing average order value. Customers perceive value — they pay less per unit — while the ecommerce business increases the amount spent per order and reduces the relative cost of acquisition and shipping.

Bundles work particularly well when the products have a natural relationship in how they are used — either together or in sequence — the saving is visible and easy for customers to calculate, and the bundle has its own name and identity rather than simply being “product A + product B”.

A well-designed bundle does not compete with the individual product — it complements it. Customers who only want one product can still buy it. Those who want to get more value from their purchase have the bundle as a clear option.

The key consideration: the bundle must not feel like a disguised discount. If customers believe the individual price has been inflated to make the bundle look like a good deal, they lose trust in the brand. The balance between perceived and actual value determines whether the bundle generates sales or distrust.

4. Cross-Selling with Complementary Products

Cross-selling involves strategically presenting products that complement the one a customer is viewing. Unlike upselling — which offers an improved version of the same product — cross-selling offers different products that enhance or complete the experience of using the main product.

In cosmetics: alongside a moisturiser, display a serum that enhances its effects. In food: alongside olive oil, show a complementary salt or vinegar. In fashion: alongside an item of clothing, display accessories that complete the outfit.

Manual cross-selling — strategically selected by the ecommerce team — converts better than automated recommendations in the early stages, when there is not enough purchase history for AI to make relevant suggestions. Over time, purchase history makes it possible to automate and improve recommendations.

The presentation should be clear, visual and unobtrusive. A well-designed cross-selling section on a product page adds value. An overcrowded section competes for the customer’s attention and can distract them from the main product.

5. AI-Powered “Frequently Bought Together” Recommendations

The “Frequently Bought Together” feature — which Shopify and most advanced platforms allow businesses to enable using artificial intelligence — shows customers products that other buyers have purchased alongside the one they are viewing. It is the automated, scalable version of cross-selling.

It is one of the most natural ways to increase average order value because it does not interrupt the decision-making process — it complements it. Customers viewing a product can see that other buyers also added X or Y, and consider whether those products make sense for them.

For this to work effectively, recommendations must be relevant — AI that suggests products with no real connection creates noise and undermines credibility. Initially, when there is not enough purchase history, it may be necessary to configure the most logical combinations manually and gradually allow AI to take over.

The total price of the combination must be visible. If customers can see at a glance how much it costs to add the recommended product, the decision becomes easier. If they have to calculate it themselves, friction increases and the likelihood of adding the product decreases.

6. Volume Discounts

Volume discounts — “buy 3, pay for 2”, “10% off when you buy 2 or more” — work well for products that are purchased regularly. Customers bring forward a purchase they would have made anyway, while the ecommerce business increases average order value and reduces the frequency of smaller orders and their associated logistics costs.

For these discounts to work without eroding profit margins or the product’s perceived value, three things need to be considered:

The discount must have a logical justification for the customer. “Buy more and save” is enough when the product is consumed regularly. Without that logic, a volume discount may suggest that the unit price was too high in the first place.

The discount must be sustainable. Before activating it, the actual profit margin must be calculated with the discount applied, including the shipping cost of the larger order.

The promotion needs to be visible on the product page, not in the cart. When customers arrive on a product page intending to buy one unit, that is the ideal moment to show them the benefit of buying three. By the time they reach the cart, they have already made their decision.

7. Samples or Low-Cost Products Added to Orders

Offer customers the option to add a sample of another product or a low-cost item — €2–€5 — as an extra to their main order. This does not significantly increase the order value, but it has two valuable secondary effects: it introduces customers to products they did not know about and can lead to future purchases of those products at full price.

In cosmetics or food ecommerce stores with extensive product catalogues, this tactic works particularly well for giving visibility to new or slow-moving products. Customers feel they are trying something new without taking a risk — the low price removes the barrier to entry.

The operational consideration: adding a sample must not complicate packaging or increase shipping costs. If the logistics cost of including the sample exceeds its selling price, the tactic loses its value.

8. Additional Product-Related Services

Add value-added options to the base product: gift packaging, personalisation, extended warranties, installation or personalised consultations. Customers pay for a service that improves their experience with the product, while the ecommerce business increases average order value without adding more stock or complex logistics.

In sectors where products have an emotional element — gifts, premium cosmetics, gourmet food — gift packaging for an additional €2–€3 has a surprisingly high uptake rate because customers were already considering it. Making that option available at the right moment simply makes their lives easier.

Personalisation — engraving a name, adding a message or choosing a colour — has the same multiplier effect for products where personal differentiation matters. And its implementation cost can be low if the process is properly automated.

The Most Overlooked Factor: Preserving Product Value

This is where many ecommerce businesses make seemingly small mistakes that have significant long-term consequences.

Every strategy aimed at increasing average order value implicitly communicates something about the value of the product. If customers perceive that there is always an offer available, they learn not to buy at full price. If discounts are frequent and aggressive, their perceived reference price decreases.

The right balance is not about avoiding promotions — it is about running the right promotions at the right time and with the right frequency.

Three practical rules:

Promotions need a reason. A seasonal bundle, a launch discount, a first-purchase incentive. A promotion without a reason is simply a lower price.

These strategies should be implemented on the product page or homepage — never at the payment stage. Interrupting the purchasing process with an offer at checkout causes more abandonment than it prevents.

Not every strategy needs to be active at the same time. An ecommerce store running all these strategies simultaneously may be communicating that its products are not worth their regular price. Rotating and carefully managing the frequency of promotions helps protect the perceived value of the product.

Summary: The 8 Strategies and When to Use Them

LeverBest Time to UseParticularly Suitable For
Free shipping with a dynamic thresholdAlways active and visibleAll ecommerce stores
UpsellingProduct page, before the cartProducts with different versions or sizes
Product bundlesAlways availableProducts with a natural connection in how they are used
Manual cross-sellingProduct pageCatalogues with complementary products
AI-powered Frequently Bought TogetherWhen sufficient purchase history is availableEcommerce stores with extensive catalogues
Volume discountsFor regularly purchased productsCosmetics, food, consumables
Samples or low-cost productsProduct launches or slow-moving productsAdditional services
Servicios adicionalesAlways availableGifts, premium products, personalisation

In this article

Do you find this interesting?

Add VILAX as a preferred source on Google and find our case studies, analyses and content on digital marketing more easily.

Frequently Asked Questions

Grow Your Ecommerce Business

Increase Average Order Value Without Sacrificing Profitability

At VILAX, we analyse pricing, profit margins and logistics before recommending any strategy to increase average order value. Because selling more per order does not always mean making more profit: if the strategy does not account for actual margins, it can increase order value while reducing profitability at the same time.